Local News
Coming Soon: Sales include buildings for future lifestyle businesses
By Gregory BaconJuly 25, 2026
5 min read
31 S. Erie St. will be the location of Paradiso Spa and Suites.
Trending
Some new lifestyle businesses are coming to Mayville
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from May 11-15. The county does not provide transaction information, but real estate documents are available for review at the clerk’s office
During this time period, Sunnyside Ventures 716, LLC purchased 11 South Erie St., Mayville for $120,000 and 31 S. Erie St., for $130,000
At 31 S. Erie St. is a sign that states “Coming soon: Paradiso Spa and Suites” which is described as a “boutique wellness retreat featuring spa services, luxury suites, relaxation, and recovery experiences.”
At 11 S. Erie St. is a sign that states “Coming soon: Performance at Paradiso” for elite training, recovery and coaching and “Fuel at Paradiso” for smoothies, protein shakes, and healthy grab and go
A post on Facebook states, “Our goal is to create spaces focused on wellness, recovery, movement, relaxation, and community right here in Mayville. Renovations are underway and we’re excited to continue breathing new life into these downtown buildings. We can’t wait to share the transformation with everyone as progress continues. Thank you for all the encouragement and support already — we’re excited for what’s ahead for our community.”
Officials with Paradiso said they don’t have an opening date scheduled yet
In a separate sale, French Creek Land Management, LLC sold 3196 Rt. 426, Mina for $480,000. Maplevale Farms purchased that address in 2025 for it to construct a new $41 million distribution facility. It had been a farm. It appears after the sale went through, the property was subdivided and this parcel piece, which is about 157 acres, was sold off. French Creek Land Management still owns a 41 acre parcel there
Also during this time, 23-25 and 27-29 E. Main St., Falconer were sold to 23 E. Main, LLC for $675,000. These downtown Falconer buildings have vacant businesses on the ground floor with apartments above them
In addition, Rapid Response Rentals, LLC sold 96, 100 and 116 Institute St., Jamestown to Clear Choice Towing, LLC for $80,000. This complex appears to be empty. In the past it has held different businesses, including an HVAC company and a vehicle repair shop
Including the sales previously mentioned, from May 11-15, there were four sales that were $300,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:
– 1011 Muriel Drive, Hanover sold for $464,000
– 2759 Bentley Ave., Ellicott sold for $383,000
Overall, from May 11-15, there were 65 transactions. The full list of sales $5,000 or higher is as follows:
A referee for Thomas Turner sold 1 Packward Way, Lakewood to U.S. Bank Trust National Association for $171,642
Steven and Jamie Halpainy sold 5532 Rt. 474, Ashville, town of Harmony, to Paul Jr. and Lori Troyer for $220,000
Andrew Hildom sold 2885 Stone Road, Poland to Mary Fales Revocable Trust for $175,000
Craig and Hannah Catalfu sold 11 South Erie St., Mayville to Sunnyside Ventures 716, LLC of Clarence, NY for $120,000
Chautauqua Inns LTD of Mayville sold 31 S. Erie St., Mayville to Sunnyside Ventures 716, LLC of Clarence for $130,000
William Harvey sold 17 Tew St., Jamestown to AAA Niagara, Inc. of Buffalo for $40,000
French Creek Land Management, LLC of Corry, Pa. sold 3196 Rt. 426, Mina to Bruce Neckers for $480,000
TNT Houses to Homes, LLC of Silver Creek sold 18 Center St., Forestville to Cody McCool and Megan Raynor for $231,959
Jebco Ogm Re Busti to William Jenkins for $147,500
Kevin and Susan Newman sold part of 3423 Fluvanna Ave. Ext., Ellicott to Thomas and Connie Gauronski for $30,000
The administrator of the Estate of Eugene Myers Jr. sold 88 Main St., Silver Creek to Pamela Jarrett for $142,900
Tracey Curtis sold 97 S. State St., Ripley to Andrew Szymanowski for $138,000
John and Alma Miller sold 2828 Rt. 76, Sherman to Owen Miller and Sally Wengard for $21,000
Grendaliz Torres sold 75 E. Sixth St., Dunkirk to J&G Enterprises WNY, LLC of Fredonia for $10,000
Jebco Ogm Rener to 23 E. Main, LLC of Morris Plains, NJ for $675,000
Dorothy Klinginsmith sold a parcel on West Lake Road, Chautauqua town to Phillip Klinginsmith for $8,000
Virtuality Commerce Collective, Inc. of Jamestown sold to Jonathan Cairo 22 Genesee St., Jamestown for $40,000; 171 Baker St., Jamestown for $40,000; and 107 McKinley Ave., Jamestown for $25,000
Lloyd and Sandra Munsee sold 128 Lakecrest Ave., Lakewood to Daphne Nama Crawford and Harry Munsie for $105,000
Mitchell Bondi sold a 67-acre parcel on Condin Road, Ellery to N Miller Property, LLC of Panama for $201,300
Nestor Segura and Alma Ramos sold 4465 Webster Rd., Pomfret to Alma Ramos for $66,050
Madison Mathews sold 14 Maple Ave., Ripley to Gratto Holdings of AltaVista, Virginia for $55,000
David and Kathleen Price sold 17 Johnson St., Fredonia to David and Julie Gorlewski for $282,000
Northeast Property Partners, LLC of Angola sold 1011 Muriel Drive, Hanover to Jason Samer for $464,000
Good School Farm Trust of Buffalo sold 1827 Straight Rd., Arkwright to Daniel Roelofs for $225,000
Richard Rogers sold 9466 Lake Ave., Portland to Derrick Smith for $75,000
Gary and Marise Danielson sold 4541 Warner Bay, Ellery to David and Karen Vanstrom for $200,000
Kickstart Properties, LLC of Ashville sold 32 Chautauqua St., Fredonia to Kevin Deering, Alicia Deering and Dolores Deering for $130,000
Mary Jo Tompkins, John Christopher and Kent Christopher sold 100 Eagle St., Fredonia to Victoria Still for $95,000
Heather White sold 93 Falconer St., Jamestown to Troy Holman for $54,000
Karl Wiggins sold a lot of Weeks St., Jamestown to Scott and Suzanne Harding for $10,000
Aaron and Sheryl Wadin sold 440 Front St., Jamestown to Kayli and Luis Rodriguez for $162,500
Rapid Response Rentals, LLC of Jamestown sold 96, 100 and 116 Institute St., Jamestown to Clear Choice Towing, LLC of Muncy, Pa. for $80,000
Sowul Properties, LLC of Willoughby Hills, Ohio sold 7 North Alleghany Ave., Ellicott to Teddy Avenue Properties, LLC of Lakewood for $80,000
Ronald and Leslie Climenhaga sold 2759 Bentley Ave., Ellicott to Michael and Amanda Welsh for $383,000
