This new bridge aimed to show US-Canada unity but instead stoked divisions
4 hours ago
Dax Melmer / Reuters
It was supposed to be a celebration marking the opening of a new international bridge connecting Detroit, Michigan and Windsor, Ontario, after eight years of construction and several delays
Canadian and American dignitaries planned to come together for the inauguration of the C$6.4bn ($4.5bn; £3.4bn) Gordie Howe International Bridge connecting the automotive hubs of each nation
Instead, Canadians will host their own event solo on Friday, having disinvited their US counterparts in the wake of Donald Trump’s latest tariff threat on their country
It’s only the most recent bit of drama for a bridge meant to symbolise unity between the long-time allies and trading partners, named after a legendary Canadian ice hockey player who played the majority of his career for the Detroit Red Wings
Now, it has come to reflect the fraught relationship between the two North American neighbours – and the pressure building on Prime Minister Mark Carney to navigate those choppy waters
Canada’s Carney under pressure to fight back against Trump tariffs
Almost 15 years ago, Canada agreed to fully pay for the bridge’s construction to bypass US political resistance and get the project, seen as necessary infrastructure to fix a trade bottleneck, moving
The bridge will help support more than C$1bn ($710m; £530m) worth of goods that pass through Windsor-Detroit crossing each day
When Canada first took on the construction project, which will be owned by both Ottawa and Michigan, it agreed to share toll revenue with the US state only once its costs were paid
Then, early this year, shortly before a planned ribbon-cutting ceremony, Trump said he would block its opening until Canada agreed to “share authority” and ownership
“We should own, perhaps, at least one half of this asset,” he said at the time
The bridge has long faced pushback from the Moroun family in Michigan, who own the neighbouring Ambassador Bridge, the busiest commercial border crossing in North America and one of the few that are privately owned
Billionaire Matthew Maroun, who is also a Trump donor, met with US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick hours before the president’s comments, according to a New York Times report
In June, Carney announced that Canada agreed to a US request to delay the opening of the bridge to allow for further negotiations
Keen to get the vital trade link open, Ottawa accepted to now split half of the bridge revenues for the next 15 years with an economic development fund “solely controlled” by the US government
Trump touted in a recent social media post the new agreement was “MUCH BETTER” for America
The bridge fallout comes against a backdrop of a challenging trade dispute with Canada and the US. While he was running to be elected prime minister, Carney vowed to solve it with an “elbows up” approach – referencing a combative style of hockey coined by the late Gordie Howe himself
Now Carney is facing pushback for conceding to a US administration that many Canadians view as treating their country unfairly
“We’re dealing with an administration like we’ve never seen before,” Colin Robertson, a former Canadian diplomat and a fellow at the Canadian Global Affairs Institute, told the BBC
“They renege on deals. They don’t follow agreements. It’s like dealing with pirates.”
Bloomberg via Getty Images
Canada has offered up a series of what the prime minister’s critics have called concessions to the White House, including scrapping a digital services tax opposed by US tech companies and removing some retaliatory tariffs
Conservative member of parliament Shuvaloy Majumdar said the whole scenario demonstrates that Canada has been negotiating “with weakness” as it tries to secure a broader trade deal with Trump
“Canadians are sick and tired of being made into a punching bag by President Trump and have the self-respect to fight for their existence and their country,” he said at a news conference. “They deserve a government that is willing to do the same thing.”
Carney is also under scrutiny for a lack of clarity around the new bridge deal, and how revenues will be shared with the US
On Thursday, he said the underlying agreement on recouping the toll revenues between Canada and the state of Michigan remains in place
The new revenue sharing deal agreed with the White House is “in parallel” to that, he said
Ontario Premier Doug Ford praised Carney for “an excellent job of getting this deal done”
Robertson said that, while what Carney agreed to is no doubt a “concession”, it is a necessary one given the importance of the span to US-Canada commerce
“This new state-of-the-art bridge was done at a great expense, and yes we paid, but it is necessary to keep supply chains intact,” he said, adding that businesses and communities on both sides of the border have been pushing to get it open
Some provincial leaders have pushed for firmer action on trade negotiations by Ottawa
Premier Ford called Trump a “bully” and said Canada should consider using its energy and critical mineral exports as leverage in trade talks
But others, like Alberta’s Danielle Smith and Saskatchewan’s Scott Moe, are urging restraint, revealing cracks in Canada’s united approach to the US
How Carney will respond is still anyone’s guess. Robertson noted that while Gordie Howe played with his “elbows up”, he would also say that “the objective is to get the puck in the net”
But Robertson added that he believes Canada has already given enough
“Any further concessions would be problematic and probably not in our interest, given the behaviour of the Trump administration up to now,” he said
Canada’s ‘powerful’ dairy sector is in Trump’s trade crosshairs
Carney looking at ‘all options’ as Trump announces 50% tariffs on Canada
Canada
Donald Trump
United States
Michigan
Ontario
Mark Carney
